Deal Ledger · Guide

How to Analyze a Rental Property, Step by Step

Cap rate, cash flow, cash-on-cash return, DSCR, and max offer — explained in plain English, with the full analyzer built right into this page so you can try it as you read.

What Deal Ledger Actually Tells You

Deal Ledger takes a rental property's numbers — or just an address — and answers three questions in under a minute:

  1. Should you pursue this deal? Cash flow, cap rate, cash-on-cash return, DSCR, and a plain-English verdict.
  2. What's the most you should offer? Enter your target return, and it calculates the maximum price that still hits your numbers — checked against real market comps.
  3. Is the price fair? Auto-pulled comps show exactly how the asking price compares to what's actually selling nearby.

No spreadsheets. No manual cap rate math. Just the numbers you need to make a fast, confident call.

What to Fill Out, Based on What You're Trying to Do

Your GoalWhat to Fill InWhat You Get
"I found a listing — is this a good deal?" Purchase price, down payment %, interest rate, loan term, monthly rent, and rough expense estimates Cash flow, cap rate, cash-on-cash return, DSCR, break-even occupancy, and a plain-English verdict
"What's the max I should offer?" Rent and expense fields, plus your target cash-on-cash return and/or target DSCR in Optional Tools The highest price you can pay and still hit your target return — checked against comps if entered
"I don't know the comps or square footage" Just the property address Auto-filled square footage, 3 nearby comps, and an estimated market value
"Is this asking price fair?" Run a comps lookup first, then enter the purchase price and run the analysis The "Value vs. Comps" metric — exactly how far above or below market the price sits
"How much negotiating room do I have?" Run the max offer calculator first, then enter your actual offer price A direct comparison showing how far your offer sits from your calculated ceiling
"I want a record to share with a partner or lender" Complete a full analysis first A clean, branded one-page PDF report — ready to save, print, or send

Quick Field Glossary

TermWhat It Means
Cap RateAnnual income ÷ purchase price. Higher generally means better income relative to what you paid — but ignores financing entirely.
Cash-on-Cash ReturnAnnual cash flow ÷ actual cash invested (down payment + closing + rehab). Accounts for financing, unlike cap rate.
DSCRDebt Service Coverage Ratio — how many times over the property's income covers the mortgage payment. Below 1.0 means it doesn't cover the loan at all. Lenders typically want 1.2+.
Break-Even OccupancyThe minimum occupancy needed to cover all costs. Lower is safer — more room to handle vacancy without losing money.
Max Offer (MAO)The highest price you can pay and still hit your target return, given your actual expenses and financing terms.

A Typical Full Workflow

  1. Find a listing — note the price, address, and estimated rent
  2. Look up comps using the address (auto-fills square footage and 3 comparable sales)
  3. Fill in your financing assumptions and operating costs
  4. Calculate your max offer using your target return
  5. Enter the actual listing price and run the analysis — see the verdict and how your offer compares to your max
  6. Save the deal and/or download the PDF to reference later or share with a partner
This tool provides estimates for planning purposes only — not financial, legal, or investment advice. Always verify rent, comps, and expense assumptions independently before making an offer.

Try it yourself, right here

Field Ledger · Deal Inspection

Rental Deal Analyzer

Enter a property's numbers. Get the cash flow, the returns, a straight verdict, and the maximum offer that still hits your target return.

Purchase
Income & Operating Costs
Optional Tools
Neither is required to run an analysis — use them to auto-fill comps or check your target return before you commit to a price.
Comps Lookup
Comp 1
Comp 2
Comp 3
Maximum Allowed Offer

Ready to analyze

—
Field Notes
Drafting summary…
This is a planning tool, not financial or investment advice. Verify all figures — especially rent and comps — before making an offer.
Saved Deals
Loading...